Cloth Nappies vs Disposable Nappies (Diapers): How to Choose for Your Baby
Cloth nappies or disposables? Compare cost, washing, skin care, and waste. Simple guide with official advice from Australia, the UK, the US and Canada.
PBy Pramod RimalPublished Updated 13 min read

On this page
- Key points
- What is the main difference between cloth and disposable nappies?
- Side-by-side comparison: cloth vs disposable nappies
- Types of cloth nappies explained simply
- Cost, time and daily routine
- Baby skin, nappy rash and hygiene
- How to wash and store cloth nappies safely
- Environmental impact: waste, water and energy
- Nappy choices by age and stage
- Safety rules and official guidance (Australia, UK, US and Canada)
- Common mistakes to avoid
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
Short answer: Both cloth nappies and disposable nappies work well. Neither option is best for every family. Disposable nappies save time on washing and suit busy trips. Cloth nappies cut down on rubbish and can save money over time. Many parents use both at different times.
In Australia and the UK, people say "nappies". In the US and Canada, people say "diapers". This guide uses both words so every parent can follow along. Health bodies in all four countries agree on the main rule. Change any nappy often to keep your baby's skin clean and dry.
Key points
- Skin health: Changing often matters more than the type of nappy you pick.
- Cost: Cloth nappies cost more to buy at the start. Disposables cost more week by week.
- Time: Cloth means extra loads of washing each week. Disposables go straight in the bin.
- Waste: Disposables go to landfill. Cloth uses water and power for washing.
- Mix and match: You do not have to pick just one type. Part-time cloth works well for many homes.
- Safety: Keep plastic nappy sacks, soaking buckets, and loose fasteners well away from babies.
What is the main difference between cloth and disposable nappies?
A disposable nappy is made to be worn once and thrown away. It has a soft inner layer that lets wee pass through. Inside, a special gel locks the liquid away from the skin. A thin plastic outer layer stops leaks. Sticky tabs hold it shut around the waist.
A cloth nappy is made of washable fabric and can be used hundreds of times. An inner cloth pad soaks up the wee. A waterproof outer shell keeps clothes dry. Most modern cloth nappies fasten with snaps or hook-and-loop tabs, much like a disposable.
You do not have to be "all cloth" or "all disposable". Some parents use cloth at home during the day. They switch to disposables overnight, at daycare, or on holiday. Even using one or two cloth nappies a day cuts down the number of disposables you buy and throw out.
Side-by-side comparison: cloth vs disposable nappies
This table shows how the two choices compare in daily life.
| Feature | Cloth nappies | Disposable nappies |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Higher, because you buy a full set at once | Low, because you buy one pack at a time |
| Ongoing cost | Mostly water, power, and laundry powder | Buying new packs every week until toilet training |
| Daily work | Rinse poo, wash every couple of days, dry, and fold | Put dirty nappy in a sealed bin |
| Rubbish | Very little rubbish; can reuse for another child | Many used nappies go to landfill |
| Outings and travel | Need to carry wet bags and bring dirty nappies home | Light to pack and easy to throw away |
| Skin and rash | Breathable fabric; needs frequent changes | Pulls wee into gel; scents or dyes can bother some babies |
| Overnight leaks | Often needs extra booster pads for heavy wetters | Easy to find overnight styles with high absorbency |
| Resale value | Good quality cloth nappies can be sold or passed on | None |
Types of cloth nappies explained simply
Old-fashioned cloth nappies needed tricky folding and sharp safety pins. Modern cloth nappies are much easier to use. Most look like regular shaped nappies with snaps.
All-in-one (AIO)
An all-in-one nappy has the absorbent pad sewn right into the waterproof cover. You put it on in one piece, just like a disposable. When it is dirty, the whole thing goes in the wash. Because all the layers stay attached, it takes longer to dry on the line.
Pocket nappies
A pocket nappy has a waterproof outer shell with a soft cloth lining. There is an opening at the back like a pocket. You slide a folded cloth pad (called an insert) inside the pocket before use. When you take it off, you pull the insert out so both parts wash and dry faster.
All-in-two (AI2) or snap-in
This style has a waterproof outer cover and a pad that snaps inside. If your baby only does a wee, you can often unsnap the wet pad and snap in a clean one. You can wipe the cover and reuse it a few times before washing it. This saves space in the washing machine.
Flats, prefolds and fitted nappies
Flats are large squares of cotton or bamboo that you fold around your baby. Prefolds are thick rectangles sewn in panels for easy folding. Fitted nappies are shaped like a nappy with elastic at the legs, made entirely of absorbent cloth. All three need a separate waterproof cover on top. They dry very fast and are often the cheapest way to use cloth.
Common cloth fabrics
- Cotton: Cheap, tough, and easy to wash. It holds a fair amount of wee and dries at medium speed.
- Bamboo: Very soft and holds a lot of liquid. It takes longer to dry than cotton.
- Hemp: Holds the most liquid of all natural fibres, great for naps and nights. It is slow to absorb, so pair it with cotton or bamboo on top.
- Microfibre: Soaks up wee fast and dries quickly. Never put microfibre straight against bare skin, as it pulls moisture out of skin and can cause dryness. Put it inside a pocket or under cotton.
Cost, time and daily routine
Money and time are the two biggest reasons parents pick one style over the other.
With disposables, you pay a small amount at the shop each week. Over two or three years, those packs add up to a large sum. Babies often use thousands of nappies before they are ready for the toilet. If you have twins or two children in nappies at once, the weekly bill grows fast.
With cloth, you pay more at the start to build a stash of nappies, covers, and wet bags. After that, your main costs are water, electricity, and laundry detergent. You can save even more if you buy clean second-hand cloth nappies, or reuse the same set for a second baby.
Time matters too. Disposables take seconds to change and bin. Cloth nappies add two or three extra loads of washing each week, plus time to hang and stuff them. Think about your home setup. Do you have your own washing machine? Do you have outdoor space or a rack to dry nappies? If you share a coin laundry or work long hours with no spare time, disposables or part-time cloth may fit your life better.
Baby skin, nappy rash and hygiene
Nappy rash is very common. It happens when wee and poo sit against soft skin for too long. Wetness makes skin weak. Poo has enzymes that irritate it. Tight nappies can also rub and make skin sore.
Official health guides in Australia (Healthdirect and Pregnancy, Birth and Baby), the UK (NHS), the US (American Academy of Pediatrics), and Canada (Canadian Paediatric Society) all share the same core advice. Neither cloth nor disposable nappies can stop nappy rash on their own. Good daily care makes the biggest difference.
Simple steps to protect your baby's skin
- Change nappies often. Change wet or dirty nappies as soon as you can. Newborns need changing very often, day and night.
- Clean gently. Use warm water and a soft cloth or cotton wool. If you use wipes, pick plain ones without scent or alcohol.
- Pat dry. Gently pat your baby's bottom dry with a clean towel. Do not rub sore skin.
- Give nappy-free time. Lay your baby on a clean towel for a short time each day. Fresh air helps red skin heal fast.
- Use a simple barrier cream. A plain cream with zinc oxide or petroleum jelly keeps wee off the skin.
A tip for cloth users: Thick, greasy nappy creams can coat cloth fabric. When fabric is coated, wee rolls right off instead of soaking in. If you need thick cream for a rash, lay a thin disposable paper liner on top of the cloth nappy, or switch to disposables for a few days until the skin heals.
When to see a doctor: Ask a doctor, nurse, or pharmacist for help if the rash does not fade after a few days. Also get help if you see blisters, open sores, pus, bleeding, bright red patches in the skin folds, or if your baby has a fever or seems in pain.
How to wash and store cloth nappies safely
Washing cloth nappies sounds hard at first, but a simple routine keeps them fresh and clean.
Dealing with poo
If your baby only drinks breastmilk, their poo dissolves in water. You can put those nappies straight into the washing machine. Once your baby starts formula or solid food, tip or scrape solid poo into the toilet first. Flush it away before storing the nappy.
Storing dirty nappies
Do not soak dirty nappies in a bucket of water. Standing water is a serious drowning risk for crawling babies and toddlers. Soaking also weakens elastic and fabric over time. Instead, use an airy dry basket or a zippered wet bag. Airflow keeps smells down until wash day.
A simple two-wash routine
- Pre-wash: Run a short cool or warm rinse cycle every day or two. This washes out wee and leftover poo so nappies do not sit in dirty water during the main wash.
- Main wash: Wash the pre-washed nappies every two to three days on a longer warm or hot cycle. Add normal baby clothes or small towels if needed so the drum is full enough for good rubbing. Use a good quality laundry powder or liquid.
- Skip fabric softener: Never use fabric softener or dryer sheets on cloth nappies. They leave a waxy layer that stops the cloth from soaking up wee.
- Dry well: Hang nappies outside in the sun when you can. Sunlight helps fade stains naturally. Keep waterproof covers out of hot tumble dryers so the waterproof layer does not melt or peel.
Environmental impact: waste, water and energy
Many parents think about the planet when choosing nappies. Both types have an impact, just in different ways.
Disposable nappies use plastics, wood pulp, and absorbent gels. Every used nappy goes into household rubbish and sits in landfill, where plastic parts break down very slowly. Making and shipping thousands of single-use nappies also uses energy and raw materials.
Cloth nappies create far less rubbish. One set of cloth nappies can last through toilet training and then be used for a younger brother or sister. However, cloth nappies still use resources. Washing and drying them takes water and power, and growing cotton uses water too.
You can lower the impact of cloth nappies with a few habits. Wash full loads instead of half loads. Use cold or warm water when you can, and hang nappies on a washing line instead of using a tumble dryer. Even if you use disposables, picking a tight-fitting size reduces leaks and saves extra outfit washes.
Nappy choices by age and stage
Your baby's needs change fast from the newborn weeks to the toddler years. What works at two weeks old may not work at twelve months.
| Age stage | What changes | Cloth tips | Disposable tips |
|---|---|---|---|
| Newborn (0 to 3 months) | Very frequent wees and runny poos. Umbilical cord stump heals in the first weeks. | Tiny legs can gap in "one-size" cloth. Try newborn-sized covers or folded flats at first. | Fold the front waistband down below the cord stump until it falls off. |
| Active baby (3 to 12 months) | More rolling, crawling, and bigger wees. Solid foods change poo. | Adjust rise snaps for a snug leg fit. Tip solid poo into the toilet before washing. | Move up a size if you see red marks on the thighs or frequent leaks. |
| Toddler (1 to 3+ years) | Heavy wees overnight. More wriggling during changes and early toilet interest. | Add a hemp or bamboo booster at night. Pull-up cloth trainers help during toilet learning. | Pull-up nappy pants can make standing changes easier for active toddlers. |
If you want to try cloth, you do not have to start on day one. Many families use disposables for the first few weeks while they recover from birth and learn their baby's rhythm. They start cloth once the umbilical cord has healed and the baby's legs fill out.
Safety rules and official guidance (Australia, UK, US and Canada)
Nappies themselves do not have a single global safety standard like car seats or cots do. Still, national safety and health bodies in all four countries warn about real hazards around nappy changing.
| Country | Official bodies | Key safety and health advice |
|---|---|---|
| Australia | ACCC / Product Safety Australia, Healthdirect, Pregnancy, Birth and Baby | Keep one hand on baby on change tables. Never leave soaking buckets in reach. Change often to prevent rash. Check recalls before buying second-hand gear. |
| United Kingdom | Office for Product Safety and Standards (OPSS), NHS, RoSPA | RoSPA warns that plastic nappy sacks can suffocate babies if kept near cots. NHS advises plain water or scent-free wipes for newborns and frequent changes. |
| United States | Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC), American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) | CPSC warns against falls from raised changing tables and unsafe straps. AAP recommends frequent changes, gentle cleaning, and air time for nappy rash. |
| Canada | Health Canada, Canadian Paediatric Society (Caring for Kids) | Health Canada tracks product recalls and warns on fall and choking risks around changing areas. Caring for Kids advises gentle water cleaning and plain barrier creams. |
Five nappy safety rules to follow at home
- Keep plastic nappy sacks away from cots: RoSPA in the UK warns that babies have died after pulling thin plastic nappy sacks over their faces. Never store a roll of nappy bags inside or next to a cot, pram, or playpen.
- Never walk away from a raised surface: Babies can roll or kick off a change table, bed, or couch before you expect it. Keep nappies, wipes, and cream within arm's reach before you lay your baby down. Keep one hand on your baby the whole time.
- Watch small fasteners: Modern snaps and tabs are safe when sewn well. Check cloth nappies now and then for cracked or loose snaps that could be a choking risk. If you use traditional pins or clips, keep them closed and far out of your baby's reach.
- Never leave water buckets on the floor: Babies and toddlers are top-heavy and can fall head-first into a bucket with just a few centimetres of water. Use a dry pail instead of soaking cloth nappies.
- Check product recalls: Before using second-hand change tables, mats, or nappy bins, check the official recall site for your country, such as Product Safety Australia or Health Canada Recalls.
Common mistakes to avoid
New parents often run into the same small traps when starting out with nappies. Avoiding these saves money and stress.
- Buying a huge set of one cloth brand too early: Every baby has a different body shape. A brand that fits a chubby-thighed baby may gap on a lean baby. Buy two or three different styles first to see what fits your baby best.
- Leaving a dry-feeling disposable on too long: Disposables feel dry on the surface even when full. Leaving one on for too many hours still traps warm moisture and germs against the skin. Check and change every few hours when awake.
- Using scented wipes or strong soaps on sore skin: Fragrance can sting red or broken skin and make nappy rash worse. Stick to warm water or plain, fragrance-free wipes.
- Using too much washing powder or softener: Leftover soap or softener in cloth nappies can cause skin irritation and leaks. Measure detergent carefully and rinse well.
- Forgetting to tuck leg ruffles out: On both cloth and disposable nappies, the soft ruffles around the legs should point outward, not tuck inside. Tucking them in causes leaks down the legs.
Frequently asked questions
Do cloth nappies cause less nappy rash than disposables?
Not always. Cloth nappies let more air move around the skin and have no added scents. That can help babies with sensitive skin. However, cloth feels wet right away, so a baby can get a rash fast if not changed soon enough. Disposable nappies pull wee away from the skin into gel, which keeps the surface drier. With either type, frequent changes are the best way to prevent rash.
Can I use cloth nappies part-time?
Yes. Many parents use cloth nappies at home during the day and disposables at night or when travelling. There is no rule saying you must choose one hundred percent cloth or one hundred percent disposable. Part-time cloth is a great way to save money and reduce rubbish without feeling overwhelmed.
How many cloth nappies do I need to start?
If you plan to use cloth full-time and wash every two to three days, most families need around 20 to 24 nappies for a baby, and a few more for a newborn who goes through more changes. If you only plan to use cloth part-time, 6 to 10 nappies is plenty to start.
Are scented wipes and nappies safe for newborns?
Newborn skin is very thin and sensitive. Health services like the NHS in the UK and Pregnancy, Birth and Baby in Australia recommend plain warm water and cotton wool or a soft cloth in the early weeks. If you prefer wipes, choose alcohol-free and fragrance-free packs to lower the chance of irritation.
What should I do with dirty disposable nappies safely?
If your baby is on solid food, you can tip solid poo into the toilet first. Wrap the dirty nappy tightly using its sticky tabs and put it straight into a bin with a lid. If you use plastic nappy sacks, tie the top knot and keep the roll of unused bags stored high up, well away from your baby's cot or changing mat.
Do daycares accept cloth nappies?
Many childcare centres are happy to use modern cloth nappies, especially all-in-one or pre-stuffed pocket styles that go on just like a disposable. Ask your centre before your baby starts. Most centres will ask you to supply enough pre-assembled nappies for the day plus a zippered wet bag to bring dirty ones home.
Sources
- healthdirect – Nappy rash
- Pregnancy, Birth and Baby – Nappy rash
- RoSPA (UK) – Nappy sacks safety
- NHS – Washing and bathing your baby
- AAP HealthyChildren.org – Diaper rash
- Caring for Kids (Canadian Paediatric Society) – Diaper rash
- Product Safety Australia – Recalls
- Health Canada – Recalls and safety alerts
Pramod Rimal
Founder & editor
Practical, evidence-led guides for Australian families. We check claims against Australian standards and official health and safety guidance, and link our sources so you can check them too.
Visit Pramod Rimal’s website →About us and how we research →
Related guides
More Bath, Nappies & Changing →
TCF vs ECF Nappies: What These Labels Mean for Your Baby
11 Oct 2026 · 12 min read
Wet-Dry Bags for Cloth Nappies and Swimwear: How to Choose and Use One
1 Oct 2026 · 14 min read
Reusable Cloth Nappies vs Disposable Nappies: Absorbency, Washing and Cost
19 Oct 2026 · 12 min read













